Thursday, September 13, 2012

This Doula Has Limits

When I was contacted about being a doula
for that young mom whose husband is deployed
and is due around Thanksgiving--
I met with her;
we talked extensively about her expectations
and ideal homebirth plan
that would include her two young children.
Then just days later,
she changed her mind about a homebirth
stating simply that she didn't care for the way
the midwife interacted with her other children.

I'm guessing the midwife saw what I saw--
two very wiggly little ones with lots of energy to spare.
Even so, I agreed to be a "sibling doula" for them
so the Momma could have them at the birth.
But, the plan changed.
The new plan was to go to a birth center in Denver.
In November.
That's an hour and a half away,
with always the chance of snow during that time of the year.
I said "yes" to the New Plan...
which included me picking the whole family up and driving to the birth center
once Mama was in labor,
tending the little ones during the labor and delivery,
packing Mama and the little ones up two-three hours after the birth,
and then driving back down to the Springs,
unloading the new family at their home
and getting everyone settled in
before I would leave to come home, shower, eat, get some rest,
and then head back within 4-6 hours
to continue on with Post-partum care.

I was on board with all of that.
There was just one more thing I wanted in place--
that another person be at the house
whenever I wasn't in the first 24 hours
to keep watch over Mama and baby.
She insisted that she didn't need anyone else there
in my absence,
that she would just take it easy and all would be well.

I shared experiences where, sadly,
that supervision was not given
and tragic outcomes occurred.
She said she'd think about it n' get back to me.

She did.
She said that because of my concerns,
she was going to get a different doula who would honor her wishes
and her birth plans--
someone who would trust her instincts over their own.

And that kinda stunk on ice.
It's a mix of unfamiliar rejection
and straight-up concern for an ignorant mother.
Aside from my own births (7 of 'em),
one of which resulted in hemorraging to the point of passing out
and having to receive blood,
two hours after a birth;
and attending home births as a midwife assistant,
and attending hospital births as a doula,
I KNOW there is liablity for a caregiver/health professional
to stay with a new mother at least 24-48 hours.
It would be irresponsible to do otherwise.
Just a flat-out dangerous risk I'm unwilling to take.

It may sound like I'm complaining about being replaced
but that's not it--
my limits are
based on training and experience.
And I know that we live in a
"have-it-your-way" culture,
but reason has to trump ego sometimes
for safety.
And the saying "better safe than sorry"
was borne from necessity,
I'm sure.

Doulas are guardians, advocates, encouraging presences
passionate about the miracle of motherhood and birth.
We are partners and educators.
We have a responsibility & commitments to keep childbirth
as safe as possible.
Anything less is unacceptable.

So, if you're a doula
know your limits.
Stand up for them. Abide them.
And if you're thinking about hiring a doula,
learn what a doula's role is in childbirth
and respect her experience and knowledge.
Trust is essential on both sides.
The miracle of birth is just that--
a miracle and demands respect and awareness.
That said,
I love being a Doula!


8 comments:

  1. Hmm, it sounds like you had a lucky escape with that particular personality.

    But I'm saddened when I read this post because in NZ the official policy is to let mothers give bith in hospital but to get them home as fast as possible, preferably within hours. My cousin, when she had her 2nd child, went home two hours after giving birth. There is such a lack of genuine care :-( And there have been tragedies - although I suspect more than we hear about.

    I'll be honest and say that I was trapped in hospital for several days after birth because I had a C-section and almost needed a transfusion, and I hated my time there, hated the evil nurses, didn't actually get any care at all, just wanted to be home. But I understand the necessity of ensuring women and babies are safe after birth. I'm so glad you do not compromise on basic standards of care.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Definitely better that she found someone else. I'm a doula also and have learned the same lesson. Listen to your instincts. Always.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good for you for standing up for yourself. I think you're smart to insist that she has someone there with her at all times for a day or two after the birth. What if something happened to one of her other children? What if the birth doesn't go as planned or she needs to transfer care or the newborn does? From one doula to another, I think you may have dodged a bullet.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I wonder if she'll find another to meet her demands, or in her words, "respect her wishes." I do know though, that she just passed up the VERY BEST.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Similar situations always make me break out into a cold sweat just thinking . . .

    As a L/D nurse . . . I can't help but be colored from my different perspective, we see many sad situations arrive by ambulance from failed home births (I know . . . I only get to see the failed home births and not all the successful, happy ever after ones) so it sorta scares the bajebee's outta me . . . and believe me some are very sad indeed. (I know this is not what you are advocating or even commenting about . . . just that as care providers we do have to set a high standard)

    So I'm grateful you take the responsibility to set the standard high and provide the care that is truly the best for the mom's out there.

    My encouragement always is if you are an educated women, you can get the birth experience you want, at the hospital with a doula and support team participating in a very personal birth experience. I'm always grateful to have a patient surrounded by a wonderful support team :)

    Kristin

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good for you for setting your limits. Good for her for knowing it wasn't what she wanted and setting her limits too.

    I hope that she has a wonderful, safe birth and recovery.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Her loss.

    And you did the right thing.

    =)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sounds like you did the right thing for you.
    I see personalities like her come through the ER (on the way to labor and delivery)....I'm exhausted by the time I get them out of my department.

    ReplyDelete

Have a Thought? Share It!